At the Tower of Joy in the Red Mountains of Dorne, Eddard Stark and six companions fought three Kingsguard knights and only Ned and Howland Reed survived. Inside, Lyanna Stark lay dying, and she made Ned promise something that shaped the rest of his life. The books give only fragments of the scene, told through Ned’s fever dreams, and the show later filled in the rest.
Why Was Lyanna in Dorne?
After the Tourney at Harrenhal and Lyanna’s disappearance, Rhaegar took her south. The tower stood at the northern end of the Prince’s Pass, in the Red Mountains of Dorne, and Rhaegar is said to have named it the Tower of Joy. When the war went badly, King Aerys sent Lord Commander Gerold Hightower to bring Rhaegar back, and Gerold, Ser Arthur Dayne (the Sword of the Morning, wielding Dawn) and Ser Oswell Whent were left guarding the tower. Rhaegar died at the Trident, and Aerys died in the Sack of King’s Landing, yet the three knights stayed. The story that led here is told in Rhaegar and Lyanna.
What the Kingsguard Were Guarding
In Ned’s memory, he tells the knights he looked for them at the Trident and they answer that they were not there. They also tell him of the Kingslayer, and one says they would not have let the Kingslayer sit the throne had they been in King’s Landing. The Kingsguard exist to protect the royal family, and their refusal to leave after both the prince and the king were dead strongly suggests they believed there was royalty still inside. That fits the show’s account that Lyanna was no prisoner and that the baby was a Targaryen heir. In the books the question is never answered directly.

The Fight: Seven Against Three
Ned’s companions were Howland Reed, Lord Willam Dustin, Ethan Glover, Martyn Cassel, Theo Wull and Ser Mark Ryswell. By the end only Ned and Howland were alive, and in Ned’s account Howland saved his life from Ser Arthur Dayne. The show’s version, seen in Bran’s vision, is brutal: Dayne cuts through the northmen, and Ned only survives because Howland stabs Dayne in the back, an act Bran finds shocking. The books suggest something un-knightly happened too, which is why Ned’s honor-bound account of beating the greatest swordsman alive never quite adds up.
Afterward Ned had the tower torn down to build cairns for the dead, and carried Dawn to Starfall to return it to House Dayne. Arthur’s sister Ashara Dayne later threw herself into the sea there, a death rumor connects to Ned and to Jon Snow’s parentage but which the books never explain.
“Promise Me, Ned”
Inside, Lyanna lay in a bed of blood, surrounded by the scent of roses, and made Ned promise something. The books never say what. Everything Ned did afterward suggests what it was: protect her son, hide his name and keep him from Robert’s fury. Ned kept that promise for fourteen years and took it to his grave.
The Ripple Effects
Jon Snow’s parentage rests on what happened here, and it makes him, in the show, a legitimate Targaryen ahead of Daenerys in the line of succession. Howland Reed is the last living witness, which is why readers still wait for him (read his profile). And the mystery of House Dayne’s grief and Ashara’s death remains one of the books’ open threads. See where Jon sits on the interactive family tree.
FAQ
Where is the Tower of Joy?
In the Red Mountains of Dorne, at the northern end of the Prince’s Pass. Ned later tore it down to build cairns.
Who survived the Tower of Joy fight?
Only Ned Stark and Howland Reed. The three Kingsguard, Gerold Hightower, Arthur Dayne and Oswell Whent, and Ned’s other companions died.
Why didn’t the Kingsguard protect Rhaegar at the Trident?
Aerys sent Gerold Hightower to bring Rhaegar back, and Gerold, Arthur Dayne and Oswell Whent were left guarding the tower. Their refusal to leave after both Rhaegar and Aerys were dead suggests they believed there was royalty inside.
What did Lyanna make Ned promise?
The books never state it. Everything Ned did afterward suggests he promised to protect her newborn son.
Is the Tower of Joy scene in the books?
Only as fragments of Ned’s fever dreams in A Game of Thrones. The full fight is on screen, in Season 6.

